Difference between revisions of "MEL Report"
DFM-Cyborg (talk | contribs) m (Updated from https://trello.com/b/HubNzjyl) |
DFM-Cyborg (talk | contribs) m (Updated from https://trello.com/b/HubNzjyl) |
||
Line 73: | Line 73: | ||
* May be written up as a paper to be submitted for peer review. | * May be written up as a paper to be submitted for peer review. | ||
| | | | ||
+ | 2021-12-21: Message from Mostafa -- "Lit. review will be finalized by 1st week of January. Dr. Taslima is working on. " | ||
+ | |||
FINAL REVIEW | FINAL REVIEW | ||
Line 97: | Line 99: | ||
* The compiled report should include a selection of key locations for in-depth research | * The compiled report should include a selection of key locations for in-depth research | ||
| | | | ||
− | 2022- | + | 2022-12-21: "Final" document shared by Mostafa. https://driedfishmatters.org/files/DFM_RPT_BGL-Key-location-report_FINAL-DRAFT_2021-12-21.docx. |
2021-12-20: Updated report shared by Taslima. https://driedfishmatters.org/files/DFM_RPT_BGL-Key-location-report_comments_DJ_08.09.21_mostafa_25.10.21%5B10327%5D_JU20.12.2021.docx. Previous version shared by Mostafa within the BGL team 2021-10-26, addressing comments from Derek. | 2021-12-20: Updated report shared by Taslima. https://driedfishmatters.org/files/DFM_RPT_BGL-Key-location-report_comments_DJ_08.09.21_mostafa_25.10.21%5B10327%5D_JU20.12.2021.docx. Previous version shared by Mostafa within the BGL team 2021-10-26, addressing comments from Derek. | ||
Line 132: | Line 134: | ||
* Uploading and tagging any references on this region that the research team locates that are not currently in DFM’s Zotero literature database | * Uploading and tagging any references on this region that the research team locates that are not currently in DFM’s Zotero literature database | ||
| | | | ||
− | Ask U of M RA (KEVIN) to go through bibliography and upload references to Zotero. | + | Ask U of M RA (KEVIN) to go through bibliography and upload references to Zotero (i.e., within the Scoping Report) |
2021-10-05: Mizoram and Manipur literature review embedded within the Scoping Report. Could be analyzed further in a subsequent document, following the Scoping research. | 2021-10-05: Mizoram and Manipur literature review embedded within the Scoping Report. Could be analyzed further in a subsequent document, following the Scoping research. | ||
+ | |||
+ | 2020-09: Email exchange between Ramachandrudu and Derek, "Summary of Review of Literature on the Dried Fish in North Eastern States of India- reg". See message forwarded by Derek 2020-10-27. Report to be filed for internal circulation. | ||
| 2020-06-07 | | 2020-06-07 | ||
|- | |- | ||
Line 228: | Line 232: | ||
* Subject to modifications agreed upon with the Project Director, the report will follow the report structure given in the document [https://driedfishmatters.org/wiki/DFM_Guideline:_Scoping_report_structure DFM Guideline: Scoping report structure]. | * Subject to modifications agreed upon with the Project Director, the report will follow the report structure given in the document [https://driedfishmatters.org/wiki/DFM_Guideline:_Scoping_report_structure DFM Guideline: Scoping report structure]. | ||
| | | | ||
+ | 2022-01-13: Derek requests that we suspend the Zotero work. Derek will write to Ramachandrudu with comments from this report, to guide the Telangana deliverables. | ||
+ | |||
2022-01-11: Sent to Wae Win. TASK: https://trello.com/c/KXtGT3lZ/17-fix-zotero-references-in-mm-report | 2022-01-11: Sent to Wae Win. TASK: https://trello.com/c/KXtGT3lZ/17-fix-zotero-references-in-mm-report | ||
Line 277: | Line 283: | ||
* Summarizes the main segments and issues in dried fish value chains in West Bengal | * Summarizes the main segments and issues in dried fish value chains in West Bengal | ||
| | | | ||
− | + | 2022-01-14: Comments sent by Eric to the DFM West Bengal team. Now move to copy-editing and prepare release. | |
2022-01-03: Update from Raktima. | 2022-01-03: Update from Raktima. | ||
Line 364: | Line 370: | ||
| | | | ||
| | | | ||
+ | 2022-01-13: Follow-up exchange between Eric and Tara. The May 02 version (with copy-edits by Steven) can be considered final. Requested citation checks on p. 9, p. 10, and table 3 as noted in the comments. Suggested releasing the report in the first week of February; offered to write a 1-2 page lay summary for the blog if Tara does not have time; proposed a 45-minute presentation (25-minute presentation of the report followed by 15-20 minutes discussion). | ||
+ | |||
2022-01-12: @ericthrift check with Tara. Himani was asking about the report, but we're not sure if Tara is still working on it? This was returned to Tara and Himani 2021-03-09 with a request from Derek for some minor revisions. | 2022-01-12: @ericthrift check with Tara. Himani was asking about the report, but we're not sure if Tara is still working on it? This was returned to Tara and Himani 2021-03-09 with a request from Derek for some minor revisions. | ||
+ | |||
+ | 2021-05-02: (UPDATED): Edited report returned by Tara. "As Steven Smelz starts working on this draft I will also give it a complete reading. I am sure Himani will also find some time to read the draft." Derek responded that the report should not require further substantive revisions. | ||
2021-09-08. With TARA for revision; working on the report. | 2021-09-08. With TARA for revision; working on the report. | ||
Line 403: | Line 413: | ||
* The report will also have the materials and methods used in sorting and drying different fishes across sites | * The report will also have the materials and methods used in sorting and drying different fishes across sites | ||
| | | | ||
+ | 2022-01-18: Email update from Tara. Setback due to COVID but the report preparation is on track. | ||
+ | |||
+ | <blockquote>We have completed all the surveys (details below). I would like to also include the rapid survey report of Jafrabad along with this. Some extra information has been collected. I will revise the draft and submit. ... The data entry is about to get over. We will be able to submit the reports on time. | ||
+ | </blockquote> | ||
+ | <code>Scoping Survey Update Type Veraval Kutch Nalsarovar Total Processors 41 33 35 109 Fishers 31 - 5 36 Wholesalers 11 5 - 16 Retailers 28 2 5 35 Total 111 40 45 196</code> | ||
+ | |||
2022-01-10: Email from Tara -- "The scoping surveys in Gujarat are all over. Currently, data entry is going on. I will mail the progress reports in a couple of days." | 2022-01-10: Email from Tara -- "The scoping surveys in Gujarat are all over. Currently, data entry is going on. I will mail the progress reports in a couple of days." | ||
Revision as of 13:09, 20 January 2022
Name | Description | Comments | Due |
---|---|---|---|
DFM Cambodia scoping report |
Waiting for revisions... 2021-05-25: Revised outline sent by Gayathri (DFM_RPT_KHM-Scoping-revised-outline.docx ) 2021-04-21: Editorial meeting (Gayathri, Derek, Eric) 2021-02-20: Draft submitted by Gayathri Lokuge (DFM_RPT_KHM-Scoping-report_DRAFT.docx ) |
2020-03-01 | |
DFM Sri Lanka Key Zone identification study |
|
2020-12-20: Published online. DFM_RPT_LKA-Key-zone-study.pdf 2020-12-20: Received from Oscar Amarasinghe. Received as PDF; no further editorial work. |
2020-03-14 |
DFM Myanmar MPLSC dataset and preliminary analysis |
|
2021-08-06: Status unknown. Datasets may already be available with NAG? | 2020-03-20 |
DFM Sri Lanka policy study |
|
2020-11-15: Published online. DFM_RPT_LKA-policy-analysis_FINAL.pdf 2020-11-05: Copy-edited by Eric Thrift. DFM_RPT_LKA-policy-analysis_FINAL.docx 2020-02-20: Received from Oscar Amarasinghe. |
2020-03-28 |
DFM Myanmar literature review |
|
2021-05: Created Zotero citations (Steven) 2021-04: Imported brief summary by Ben: Dried fish in Myanmar |
2020-04-10 |
DFM Bangladesh literature review |
|
2021-12-21: Message from Mostafa -- "Lit. review will be finalized by 1st week of January. Dr. Taslima is working on. " FINAL REVIEW 2021-04-21 Created links to Zotero, Steven Smeltz. DFM_RPT_BGL-literature-review-Zotero-links_2021-04-21.docx 2020-10-31 Final draft submitted. DFM_RPT_BGL-literature-review_2020-10-31.docx |
2020-04-16 |
DFM Sri Lanka Development interventions study |
|
2020-11-15: Published online. DFM_RPT_LKA-development-interventions_FINAL.pdf 2020-11-12: Copy-edited by Eric. DFM_RPT_LKA-development-interventions_FINAL.docx 2020-02-20: Received from Oscar Amarasinghe |
2020-04-19 |
DFM Bangladesh key locations report |
|
2022-12-21: "Final" document shared by Mostafa. https://driedfishmatters.org/files/DFM_RPT_BGL-Key-location-report_FINAL-DRAFT_2021-12-21.docx. 2021-12-20: Updated report shared by Taslima. https://driedfishmatters.org/files/DFM_RPT_BGL-Key-location-report_comments_DJ_08.09.21_mostafa_25.10.21%5B10327%5D_JU20.12.2021.docx. Previous version shared by Mostafa within the BGL team 2021-10-26, addressing comments from Derek. 2021-09-08: Response from Derek. DFM_RPT_BGL-Key-location-report_comments_2021-09-08.docx . Suggestions: (1) The addition of a short statement of methodology that explains how the data for the report were gathered, by whom, and using what methods. (2) A glossary of key Bangla terms used in the report. (3) There is some inconsistency in use of terms and spellings in the report. It would be ideal if these were to be harmonized. 2021-08-06: Still on Derek's desk. TODO: Derek send comments to Taslima by 2021-08-11. 2021-04-08: Preliminary comments by Derek. DFM_RPT_BGL-Key-location-report_comments.docx 2021-03-27: Draft received from Taslima. DFM_RPT_BGL-Key-location-report_2021-03-26.docx |
2020-05-06 |
DFM Myanmar consumption survey |
|
2021-10-15: Status update from Wae Win. Work on the report is continuing; a version will be presented in the e-book as Dried Fish Consumption in Myanmar; Wae Win will upload images. DFM_RPT_MMR-Consumption-survey_2021-10.docx 2021-08-06: TODO - Eric check with Ben about finishing the report, including options for involving Si Thu. 2021-05-21: Images and text imported to wiki by Steven Smeltz. DFM Myanmar consumption survey 2021-03-18: Forwarded by Ben Belton. "I was able to ask an intern to have a first go at editing Sithu’s report on dried fish consumption in Myanmar – it still needs some refining, adding a proper introduction and conclusion, and some contextualization using secondary sources (e.g. need to compare the levels of consumption reported here with those reported elsewhere), but it is a good start." DFM_RPT_MMR-Consumption-survey_2021-03-18.docx 2020-12-11: First draft completed by Si Thu |
2020-05-16 |
VSS Review of literature on dried fish in India's northeastern states |
|
Ask U of M RA (KEVIN) to go through bibliography and upload references to Zotero (i.e., within the Scoping Report) 2021-10-05: Mizoram and Manipur literature review embedded within the Scoping Report. Could be analyzed further in a subsequent document, following the Scoping research. 2020-09: Email exchange between Ramachandrudu and Derek, "Summary of Review of Literature on the Dried Fish in North Eastern States of India- reg". See message forwarded by Derek 2020-10-27. Report to be filed for internal circulation. |
2020-06-07 |
DFM West Bengal Mapping of major fishing areas and groups |
|
2022-01-03: Message from Raktima on the Systematic Literature Review.
|
2020-06-15 |
DFM Sri Lanka literature review |
|
2021-04-05: Final edits incorporated by Eric Thrift. Source text and images are in the wiki; contents listed at DFM Sri Lanka literature review. 2021-04-04: Final draft submitted by Dilanthi Koralagama 2021-01-16: Copy-edited by Steven Smeltz 2020-11-15: Submitted by Dilanthi Koralagama, with acknowledgements to Nireka Weeratunge and Oscar Amarasinghe |
2020-07-01 |
DFM Myanmar W&R and F&P report I | 2020-07-23 | ||
DFM Myanmar Nutrition report | 2020-08-15 | ||
DFYWA Fishmeal and dried fish in Andhra Pradesh report |
2021-08-25: Revised draft received from Dasu. DFM-DFYWA_RPT_Living-on-the-edge_2021-08-25.docx . "I am attaching the final report as prepared by Mr Venkatesh with this mail. You may please get the DFM and SSHRC logos added on the cover as you suggested and upload it on the DFM website. Please send the link once it has been published digitally so we can start sharing it to other interested parties." 2021-07-16: Reviewer comments from Derek to Dasu. See "appraisal". "I think there’s real potential for an academic publication from the report. I realize this may not be your priority, but I would be happy to discuss options for helping you to transform it into an academic article if you were interested. Ratana is also putting together an e-book on outputs from the scoping phase of the project for a public audience, and we’d love to include a short piece from DFYWA in that. The volume will be free and written in accessible language, with lots of illustrations, so should be a good way to get our preliminary findings out." DFM-DFYWA_RPT_Living-on-the-edge_DRAFT-01_comments-DJ.docx 2021-04-22: Draft received from Dasu |
2020-08-15 | |
DFM Karnataka production and market survey |
|
2020-09-25 | |
DFM Myanmar Report summarizing fisheries governance and technical interventions | 2020-10-18 | ||
DFM Karnataka scoping report |
|
2020-10-30 | |
DFM Karnataka literature review |
|
2020-11-30 | |
DFM Mizoram and Manipur scoping report |
|
2022-01-13: Derek requests that we suspend the Zotero work. Derek will write to Ramachandrudu with comments from this report, to guide the Telangana deliverables. 2022-01-11: Sent to Wae Win. TASK: https://trello.com/c/KXtGT3lZ/17-fix-zotero-references-in-mm-report 2021-10-05: Comments from Derek. Suggestion to add more empirical description of value chain and links to primary demographic data, which should be provided. DFM_RPT_VSS_Scoping-NE-States-of-India_2021-06_DJ.doc To be copy-edited with DFM Central; send specific questions to Ramachandrudu as they emerge 2021-08-06: Under review. TODO: Derek to complete review by 2021-08-11; schedule copy editing (language and presentation) 2021-06-14: Draft report submitted. DFM_RPT_VSS_Scoping-report.doc |
2021-02-02 |
DFM Myanmar Value chain scoping report | 2021-03-31 | ||
DFM Thailand Review of government policies related to dried fish |
|
2021-04-30 | |
DFM Thailand literature review |
|
Check with NOVA. This report can focus on analysis of secondary data, not just publications specifically related to dried fish. It will be useful to have market data, etc., in a distinct report prior to the final Scoping report. 2021-03-12: Few Thai publications discovered by the team. Available literature was used in guiding the scoping research. NOVA is working on this. |
2021-05-15 |
DFM Myanmar F&P and W&R report II | 2021-05-31 | ||
DFM Myanmar Scoping report | 2021-05-31 | ||
DFM West Bengal Markets and market segments overview |
This corresponds to "Scoping Report #1" from the original TOR.
|
2022-01-14: Comments sent by Eric to the DFM West Bengal team. Now move to copy-editing and prepare release. 2022-01-03: Update from Raktima. Revisions are in https://driedfishmatters.org/files/DFM_RPT_WBG_Scoping_rev03_2022-01-03.docx 2021-12-03: Comments from Derek.
DFM_RPT_IITK_Revised-Scoping-Report-01_2021-11-26.docx 2021-10-18: Comments from Derek.
2021-08-18: Updated draft received from Raktima. DFM_RPT_WBG-Scoping-01_2021-08-18.docx and DFM_RPT_WBG-Scoping-01_Comments-DJ_2021-06_Explanations.pdf 2021-07-19: Returned to Jenia with comments from Derek. Requested section addressing methods. DFM_RPT_WBG-Scoping-01_Comments-DJ_2021-06.pdf 2021-06-27: Draft received from Jenia. DFM_RPT_WBG-Scoping-01_2021-06.pdf |
2021-06-15 |
DFM Thailand summary report on dried fish value chain governance |
|
2021-09-01 | |
DFM Thailand scoping report |
|
2022-02-10: Update from Ratana.
Proposal to review the agreement / research plan at that time, potentially reconsidering the role for Nova due to travel restrictions imposed by MUN. Derek proposes organizing a webinar. 2021-03-12: Most field research completed, other than East coast and two provinces under lockdown near Bangkok. Expected completion in April 2021. 2021-03: Agreed to combine "Report on rapid appraisal of dried fish value chains" into the Scoping report, with reflection on the contribution of “pre-Scoping” exploratory research to the data process. Suggested to provide some figures and tables prior to the final report, to assist comparative study. Specifically: list of fish species, table of imported/exported products, geographic data (for mapping in late 2021). |
2021-11-15 |
DFM Andhra Pradesh Report on the secondary data analysis |
|
2021-12-01 | |
DFM West Bengal scoping report 02 |
|
2021-12-15 | |
DFM Gujarat literature review |
|
2021-12-30 | |
DFM Gujarat policy review |
2022-01-13: Follow-up exchange between Eric and Tara. The May 02 version (with copy-edits by Steven) can be considered final. Requested citation checks on p. 9, p. 10, and table 3 as noted in the comments. Suggested releasing the report in the first week of February; offered to write a 1-2 page lay summary for the blog if Tara does not have time; proposed a 45-minute presentation (25-minute presentation of the report followed by 15-20 minutes discussion). 2022-01-12: @ericthrift check with Tara. Himani was asking about the report, but we're not sure if Tara is still working on it? This was returned to Tara and Himani 2021-03-09 with a request from Derek for some minor revisions. 2021-05-02: (UPDATED): Edited report returned by Tara. "As Steven Smelz starts working on this draft I will also give it a complete reading. I am sure Himani will also find some time to read the draft." Derek responded that the report should not require further substantive revisions. 2021-09-08. With TARA for revision; working on the report. 2021-05-10: Zotero references checked/added by Steven Smeltz; text copyedited based on version from Tara. Still need to insert some missing citations (DFM_RPT_GUJ-policy-review_copyedits-SS_2021-06-04.docx ) 2021-03-09: Returned to authors with comments by Derek (DFM_RPT_GUJ-policy-review_comments-DJ_2021-06-07.docx ) Comment from Derek:
2020-12-03: Draft (“reworked paper”) received from Tara Nair (DFM_RPT_GUJ-policy-review_2020-03-27.docx ) 2020-01-12: First draft |
2021-12-30 | |
DFM Bangladesh report on food security and nutrition |
|
2022-03-16 | |
DFM Gujarat field survey compilation |
|
2022-03-31 | |
DFM Gujarat report on the rapid survey on dried fish value chains in Gujarat |
|
2022-01-18: Email update from Tara. Setback due to COVID but the report preparation is on track.
2022-01-10: Email from Tara -- "The scoping surveys in Gujarat are all over. Currently, data entry is going on. I will mail the progress reports in a couple of days." 2021-02-22: Reviewed by Derek DFM_RPT_GUJ_Jafrabad-Note-based-on-rapid-scoping-study-pilot_DJ.docx 2021-02-18: Jafrabad rapid scoping research completed; field report submitted. DFM_RPT_GUJ_Jafrabad-Note-based-on-rapid-scoping-study-pilot.docx |
2022-03-31 |
DFM Andhra Pradesh Report on the primary data analysis by CESS |
|
2022-04-30 | |
DFM Sri Lanka fisher and producer focus group reports |
|
2022-05-13 | |
DFM West Bengal scoping report 03 |
|
2022-08-01 | |
DFM Andhra Pradesh Report or chapter |
|
2022-08-01 | |
DFM Bangladesh policy inventory and gap analysis report | The report should be approximately 20-30 pages, not including technical appendices, and should include the following elements: * An overview of existing policies on fish and dried fish * An identification of policy gaps * An evaluation of the policy formulation process, describing the participation of different stakeholders * An assessment of implementation gaps * A list of possible policy interventions * An assessment of key governance issues such as the role of local government, policies for common-property water bodies, and management structures * An assessment of the use of chemicals and the impact of policies concerning their import, sale, and use. | Not yet started? | 2022-08-02 |
DFM Sri Lanka nutrition study |
|
2022-08-19 | |
DFM Telangana Scoping study |
|
2021-10-05: Draft is prepared, with a similar structure to the Mizoram and Manipur report but with additional case studies and interpretation. To be shared soon. | 2022-09-01 |
DFM West Bengal final scoping report |
|
2022-10-15 | |
DFM Sri Lanka wholesale and retail research report |
|
2022-10-26 | |
DFM Andhra Pradesh Report on value chains including the retail segment |
|
2022-11-01 | |
DFM Andhra Pradesh Field Survey on value chains including the retail segment |
|
2022-11-01 | |
DFM Gujarat report on value chain financing of dried fish |
|
2022-11-30 | |
DFM Gujarat financing survey compilation |
|
2022-11-30 | |
DFM Bangladesh scoping report |
|
2022-12-02 | |
DFM Sri Lanka scoping report |
A 50-60 page scoping report, including (but not limited to) the following elements:
|
2022-12-15 | |
DFM Gujarat report on consultative workshop on Dried Fish in Gujarat |
|
2022-12-30 |